Slipped in among a few dozen headlines on the front page of most nationwide news sites this morning is the simple sentence “S.D. carries out first execution in 60 years.” It would have been easy to miss or even ignore this piece, with so many other articles vying for my mouse click, such as the passing of Lady Bird Johnson, the discovery of a frozen baby mammoth, and a woman who nearly died from a bikini wax. (Diabetics be warned!) However, I’d been following this story ever since my husband and I fell in love with the Black Hills last month and I ran across it while daydreaming about returning to the Coyote State.
I don’t normally post about political things or current events and rarely even watch the news. I figure if it gets bad enough, someone will let me know. But this story haunted me, and I found myself reading more about it, including opinion columns as well as blogs from both friends of the accused and the deceased. In March of 2000, a trio of teenagers decided it would be fun to rob their “friend” of a Chevy Blazer and other miscellaneous items. Influenced by drugs and alcohol, at some point they feared the theft victim would rat them out, so the decision was made to kill him. They apparently had no set method of carrying out their sentence, so, while Chester Allan Poage (19) begged for his life, they hauled him to a gulch, forced him into a near-frozen stream, and proceeded to beat, stab, stone, kick, and torture him for several hours until he finally succumbed. Ironic, since the state’s governor stayed this execution last August so the legislature could deliberate the most humane method of killing one of Poage’s killers, Elijah Page (pictured).
I am not ecstatic that Elijah Page, who was 18 at the time of Poage’s attack, has joined his victim in death. Although I do believe his crime is an appropriate chapter to reopen South Dakota’s capital punishment book, which has lain dormant for six decades. Page expressed remorse for his actions, requested to die, and ceased all appeals. One of Page’s accomplices waits on death row and the third has received a sentence of life without parole. I’m not opposed to the death penalty, but to me, this entire situation is just very sad due to the ages of those involved.
Why did this story haunt me? I’m not sure. But perhaps it’s because I’m the mother of both an 18- and a 19-year-old.



